In “Hardpan Song,” a narrator considers how terrible weather is relatable when you’re feeling down and out.

Track: “Hardpan Song”
Album: All Hail West Texas (2013 reissue)

Merge Records reissued All Hail West Texas in 2013 with seven additional tracks. The original 2002 release is a turning point for John Darnielle, and you’ll find lots of devotees who call it the best album he’s released. It has several iconic songs and straddles all the moods of a great Mountain Goats album from deep and personal depression to boundless and triumphant love. The seven additional tracks on the 2013 release include an alternate take of “Jenny” and some really interesting oddities, with the main connective tissue being that they all sound like they would have made sense on All Hail West Texas from the start.

“Hardpan Song” opens with a sample from the radio and sounds like so many songs from the first decade of the Mountain Goats. In the liner notes of the reissue John Darnielle says as much and says that it doesn’t really feel right for the album. It’s definitely classic Darnielle, with the incongruous jazz and then a low, quiet musing about plant growth and how it’s just like his own sad existence.

Hardpan is soil that won’t keep water and thus won’t grow anything. The narrator thinks about hardpan and how ruined soil seems like it’s ruined forever, but then it rains and rains sometimes. They snarl “it shows no signs of stopping” and it’s clear that the miserable conditions evoke something else. It’s too brief for us to know exactly what situation is at play here, but the tense guitar and “the rain comes // it floods the town // and kills everybody in it” tell us that it’s not a great day in Texas. “Hardpan Song” is essentially a musing on “when it rains it pours,” but with typical Mountain Goats flourish.