One of the most requested songs but also a song with some baggage, “Going to Georgia” asks you to really think about the narrator’s bias.
Track: “Going to Georgia”
Album: Zopilote Machine (1994)
There is no denying “Going to Georgia.” It’s the first song from the “old days” that clicks with a lot of people and it really carries the emotion of what those days were like. You have songs like “Family Happiness” and “Baboon” that show people in difficult situations with fury behind their eyes, but it is never as clear and never as direct as the sad narrator of “Going to Georgia.” The thing is, it requires you to not really be paying that much attention to love it that way. I heard it hundreds, maybe thousands, of times before John Darnielle started talking about how he was phasing it out.
The delivery is exceptional and the “most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it’s you // and that you’re standing in the doorway” lines are perfect for the moment, but the moment is a cruel one. When you’re young, it’s easy to romanticize big gestures. I’m a huge fan of “Korean Bird Paintings” because it’s always seemed to have the same idea but with less violence. Both songs are about a lover making a big show of what they think is love but really is a misguided idea. In “Korean Bird Paintings” they just waste their money on worthless things, but here they show up with a gun. It’s a huge moment, sure, and John Darnielle sells it and that’s why you love it, but it’s not a character to praise. John Darnielle is right, of course, and it’s worth reckoning with why you like this song. If you still listen to it, which I think you can, you just need to be sure you’re processing it correctly.